While in Indiana last week, I spent some time at the state History Center and Library. Randomly searched its catalog for one of my favorite Indiana-born songwriters, Hoagy Carmichael, and turned up this political curiosity: a campaign song of sorts for Senator James E. Watson. who served from 1916-1933. (Watson had previously been a member of the U.S. House of Representatives from two separate districts: the 4th district from 1895-97 and the 6th district from 1899-1909.)
Watson was a controversial and powerful Republican. He’d been a lobby in between serving in the House and Senate, had seats on important committees, was Majority Leader for his last two terms, and was a must-have endorsement in Indiana. He was suspected of being a member of the Ku Klux Klan, and got in a royal pissing match with Knute Rockne about tensions between the Klan and Notre Dame University. But outwardly his reputation apparently was of being immensely likeable and even tolerant.
There are no such complications, contradictions or nuances in Hoagy Carmichael’s song “Our Jim,” which is distinctive mainly for its obsequious nonsense in search of familiarizing and deformalizing the imperious Senator Watson.
“Our Jim” was published in late 1932, four years after Carmichael’s still-massive hit “Stardust” first debuted and just a year after its major recording by Bing Crosby. Carmichael hadn’t hooked up with lyricist Johnny Mercer just yet, but he was a well-known composer and of course, to Sen. Watson, a fellow Hoosier and Republican.
OUR JIM
Words and music by Hoagy Carmichael
Senators come from everywhere
To give the country what is fair
Some of them grow to be famous men
But some don’t even care
Senator James E. Watson came
To lead us up a rocky hill
So he proposed a tariff bill
We’ll ride along with him
OUR JIM
We call him Senator Jim
OUR JIM
And ev’ry heart is with him
Hail! To the years he gave his Hoosier State
He’s only sixty-eight
We’re mighty proud to have “Our Jim.”
A finer man couldn’t be.
OUR JIM
There’s none as handsome as he.
OUR JIM
You can bank on the Wabash
and Senator Watson
We all love Jim.
Senators are a funny crew.
They argue till they’re black and blue.
Some of them gain their points, it’s true.
But others seldom do.
Senator James E. Watson is a fiery man
With lots of vim
He never fails to gain his point
We’ll ride along with him
OUR JIM